BH
89
Source Burghound
Issue Issue 28
Drink Dates
2007+
Very ripe aromas of cherry liqueur, menthol and blueberry merge into spicy, delicious, rich, opulent and distinctly lush flavors that offer good volume and pretty good depth but not much delineation on the otherwise very long and notably warm finish. This is a hedonistic wine that is as much about its style as it is about the underlying material and I suspect that as a consequence, it will polarize pinot lovers. Those who enjoy the lush and seductive school will find much to admire and those who want more elegance and detail will look elsewhere. For me, it's a bit too warm on the finish for me to warm up to it but in the context of the style that it's made in, it's a fine example as there are no edges to be seen.
Professional content appears courtesy of Vinfolio
IWC
88(+?)
Source International Wine Cellar
Issue Issue 132
Bright, dark red. Crushed berries, musky espresso and mocha on the nose. Juicy and primary, with very fresh but slightly clenched flavors of crushed raspberry and maraschino cherry. This has shape and intensity but is distinctly tight today, finishing with firm-edged, dusty tannins.
Professional content appears courtesy of Vinfolio
WA
92
Source Wine Advocate
Issue 168
Drink Dates
2006-2012
The aromatics of his dense ruby-colored 2005 Pinot Noir Hellenthal Vineyard bring to mind an Indonesian market. Spicy, sweet cherry, and chocolaty aromas are followed by a powerful, full-bodied, harmonious, sexy Pinot to enjoy over the next 5-6 years.
Professional content appears courtesy of Vinfolio
WS
91
Source Wine Spectator
Drink Dates
2007-2011
Intense and concentrated, with a complex mix of earthy raspberry, black cherry, mineral and spice, gaining depth and richness on a long, persistent finish. The tannins are firm and ripe. 100 cases made.
Professional content appears courtesy of Vinfolio